top of page

"Discover the Sweet History and Irresistible Recipe for St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake"

St. Louis, Missouri, is renowned for its unique culinary delight: the Gooey Butter Cake. This sweet treat has become an emblematic dessert of the city, with various local coffee shops, bakeries, and restaurants offering their own twist on the classic. The Gooey Butter Cake has not only captured the hearts of locals but has also become a must-try for visitors. This article will guide you through some of the best spots in St. Louis to indulge in this buttery, rich confection, exploring the traditional varieties as well as innovative spins that cater to every palate.

Key Takeaways

  • Park Avenue Coffee is a crowd favorite, voted as having the best Gooey Butter Cake in St. Louis, with a staggering 76 varieties including Red Velvet and Triple Chocolate.

  • The Mud House and Russell's on Macklind are highly praised for their Gooey Butter Cakes, with customers lauding their phenomenal and amazing offerings.

  • Missouri Baking Company and The London Tea Room are celebrated for their traditional and innovative versions of the Gooey Butter Cake, like the Pumpkin Gooey Butter Bar.

  • Broadway Oyster Bar and Vin de Set offer unique dessert experiences, pairing unconventional items like alligator cheesecake and maple cheesecake with the classic Gooey Butter Cake.

  • Local reviews emphasize the importance of pairing coffee with Gooey Butter Cake, highlighting the complementary flavors and the overall experience.

The Sweet Spot of St. Louis: Gooey Butter Cake

Park Avenue Coffee: A Local Favorite

Nestled in the heart of Lafayette Square, Park Avenue Coffee offers a cozy retreat for coffee aficionados and cake lovers alike. With a staggering 76 varieties of gooey butter cake, this local gem has become a beacon for those seeking to indulge in St. Louis's signature dessert. Favorites like the Red Velvet and Triple Chocolate stand out, but the Original remains a timeless classic.

The coffee shop's reputation for quality is echoed in customer testimonials, with many declaring it as one of the best spots for coffee and gooey butter cake in the city. The ambiance of the location provides a perfect backdrop for social gatherings or a peaceful moment alone with a cup of joe.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Park Avenue Coffee's welcoming atmosphere and exceptional offerings are not to be missed. Here's a quick glimpse at what makes this coffee shop a must-visit destination:

  • 76 varieties of gooey butter cake

  • Voted best Gooey Butter Cake in St. Louis

  • Excellent coffee paired with delectable cakes

  • A great location for meeting friends or enjoying some quiet time

The Mud House: Where Coffee Meets Confection

Nestled in the heart of Benton Park, The Mud House stands as a beacon for those seeking the perfect blend of coffee and confection. Patrons rave about the gooey butter cake, a St. Louis specialty that has found a loving home at this cozy coffee shop. The Mud House's version of this classic treat has been described as 'phenomenal' and 'the best in the city,' earning it a loyal following.

Regulars often find themselves torn between the mascarpone cheesecake, praised for its creamy texture and tart green apple notes, and the gooey butter cake, which has become a must-try item. Here's what some of the visitors had to say:

  • Andrea A: "The gooey butter cake is phenomenal."

  • Glenn Logan: "The dirty chai is outstanding, plus the gooey butter cake is the best in the city!"

  • Andy Hyland: "Get the gooey butter cake, it's fucking awesome."

Whether you're a local or just passing through, The Mud House invites you to pause and savor the moment, one delicious bite at a time.

Baileys' Chocolate Bar: Indulgence Redefined

At Baileys' Chocolate Bar, the experience goes beyond the ordinary, offering a symphony of chocolate-inspired desserts that tantalize the taste buds. With an impressive rating of 8.2, this Lafayette Square gem is renowned for its unique takes on classic treats. Patrons rave about the Chocolate Cake Shot and the Mascarpone cheesecake, which is described as creamy, sweet, and with a hint of tartness from green apple.

Whether you're ending your meal with a decadent dessert or simply indulging in a sweet escape, Baileys' Chocolate Bar redefines indulgence. The establishment's commitment to quality and innovation ensures that each visit is a memorable one.

A Taste of Tradition: Exploring Varieties of Gooey Butter Cake

Missouri Baking Company: A Legacy of Sweetness

Stepping into the Missouri Baking Company is like taking a trip back in time to when recipes were treasured family secrets and every cake was made with a generous dollop of love. The Gooey Butter Cake here is not just a dessert; it's a slice of St. Louis history. Patrons like Amber Herrera rave about its unmatched quality, declaring it the best in the city.

The bakery's reputation is built on more than just its signature cake. Customers like Brian Johnson praise the variety of baked goods, from the Italian loaf to the specialty breads like blueberry pound cake. The service, often described as warm and welcoming, adds to the charm of this local gem.

While the gooey butter cake might have been an accidental invention in the 1930s, today it stands as a deliberate testament to the city's culinary prowess. Celebrated on National Gooey Butter Cake Day every August 12th, this confection continues to win hearts and taste buds across generations.

Russell's on Macklind: Home of the Chocolate Chip Gooey Butter Cake

Nestled in the heart of The Southampton neighborhood, Russell's on Macklind stands out as a beacon for dessert lovers. Patrons rave about the chocolate chip gooey butter cake, a unique twist on the St. Louis classic that has earned the cafe a reputation for having the 'best gooey butter cake in town.'

While the chocolate chip gooey butter cake is a must-try, the cafe also offers a variety of other delectable treats. Here's what customers say:

  • Lauren Grigg: 'Eat a piece of chocolate torte or chocolate chip gooey butter cake and enjoy the lovely atmosphere.'

  • Justin Thorp: 'Amazing gooey butter cake. Great sandwiches and salads.'

If you're planning a visit, take note of the cafe's details:

The London Tea Room: A Twist with Pumpkin Gooey Butter Bar

The London Tea Room, nestled at 3128 Morganford Rd, is a quaint spot that offers a unique take on the classic St. Louis dessert with their Pumpkin Gooey Butter Bar. Patrons like Joshua Littrell rave about the bar's perfect blend of seasonal spice and sweet, creamy goodness, making it a must-try for both locals and visitors.

The experience of enjoying a slice of gooey butter cake at The London Tea Room is about more than just indulging in a sweet treat; it's about embracing a piece of St. Louis culture. The Tea Room's commitment to quality is evident in their high-quality loose leaf teas and the care they put into each baked confection.

Beyond the Cake: Complementary Delights in St. Louis

Broadway Oyster Bar: From Alligator Cheesecake to Gooey Butter Cake

At the heart of St. Louis's vibrant culinary scene, Broadway Oyster Bar stands out not only for its unique alligator cheesecake but also for its sublime gooey butter cake. Patrons rave about the traditional and red velvet versions, each earning its own following for their delectable flavors.

The restaurant's reputation is well-earned, with a Foursquare rating of 9.1 and a spot on the list of 'The 15 Best Places for Cake in St Louis'. It's a must-visit for anyone looking to experience the full range of what St. Louis has to offer, from the adventurous alligator cheesecake to the comforting sweetness of gooey butter cake.

The Cakery Bakery: Red Velvet and More

Nestled in the heart of Clayton-Tamm, The Cakery Bakery stands out not just for its signature red velvet cake, but for the warmth and friendliness that greets every customer. This small dessert shop has become a beacon for those seeking a sweet treat, with patrons like James Robertson praising its delicious offerings and the pleasant experience provided by the staff.

While The Cakery Bakery is renowned for its wedding cakes and special occasion delights, it's their everyday baked goods that keep locals coming back. From the classic cookie cake to the irresistible red velvet, there's a confection for every palate. Julie Miller's endorsement is a testament to the bakery's commitment to quality and service, making it a must-visit for anyone in St. Louis.

Vin de Set: French Flair with Maple Cheesecake

Nestled in the heart of Downtown West, Vin de Set stands out as a beacon of French culinary tradition in St. Louis. With a rating of 8.5, this French Restaurant is not just about the main course; it's a complete experience that culminates with a dessert that has patrons raving. The Maple Cheesecake comes highly recommended, with Blake E's succinct endorsement: "Need a dessert choice? Two words: Maple Cheesecake." This sweet treat is a must-try for anyone seeking the perfect finish to their meal.

For those who have savored the delights of Vin de Set, the consensus is clear. Brandy M. describes the experience as the best dinner in St. Louis, with the escargot and cheesecake taking your tastebuds to heaven. It's not just about the food; it's about the memories created around the table, with each bite of the Maple Cheesecake serving as a sweet memento of St. Louis's culinary landscape.

The Connoisseur's Guide to Gooey Butter Cake Hotspots

The Cup: Cupcake Shop with a Gooey Twist

Nestled in the heart of Central West End, The Cup stands out not just for its signature cupcakes but for its unique take on the St. Louis classic, Gooey Butter Cake. Patrons rave about the Gold Rush, a delightful blend of yellow cake and chocolate icing, and the seasonal Italian Creme, a light French vanilla cake adorned with toasted coconut and buttercream frosting.

Despite the high praise, some customers express a longing for vanilla over almond extract, highlighting the shop's commitment to distinctive flavors. The Cup's dedication to quality and variety is evident, with moist cakes that leave a lasting impression.

While the debate over flavor extracts continues, The Cup's gooey butter cake remains a beloved treat among locals, securing its place as a must-visit destination for dessert aficionados in St. Louis.

The London Tea Room: Quality and Variety in Cakes

The London Tea Room stands out as a beacon of British tradition amidst the bustling streets of St. Louis. Visitors are greeted with an array of in-house baked goods, each promising a taste of authenticity and comfort. The Tea Room's Pumpkin Gooey Butter Bar has been lauded for its unique twist on the St. Louis classic, while the Lemon Blueberry Cake emerges as a moist and flavorful delight that has captured the hearts of locals.

Here's what patrons have to say about their experience:

  • Joshua Littrell describes the Lemon Blueberry Cake as "ssssooooo good!"

  • Kara Kirchherr praises the high-quality loose leaf tea and the delicious scones.

The London Tea Room not only serves as a haven for tea enthusiasts but also stands as a testament to the versatility and enduring appeal of the Gooey Butter Cake.

Riverfront Times' Picks: In-House Baked Goodness

The Riverfront Times has long been a trusted source for the best local eats, and their selection of in-house baked delights is no exception. STL Steak and Cake has recently opened its doors in Tower Grove South, bringing a fresh venue for cake connoisseurs to explore. Located at 4278 Connecticut Street, this new establishment is reviving a once-vacant storefront with its unique combination of savory steaks and sweet treats.

The Riverfront Times' list is not just about the latest openings; it's a celebration of the city's ongoing love affair with baked goods. From the wall-to-wall shelves of Diana's, brimming with fresh items daily, to the cozy corners of Sanctuaria, where the empanadas and tres leches cake have locals raving, the guide is a testament to St. Louis's diverse and delicious bakery scene.

Customer Acclaims and Secret Recipes

Local Reviews: What St. Louisians Are Saying

St. Louis locals have a sweet spot for their iconic Gooey Butter Cake, and their reviews reflect a city proud of its culinary delight. Each bite is filled with crispy tops and creamy middle textures, as one customer raved about the Prairie City Bakery's version. The richness and sweetness of these cakes are consistently praised, making them a must-try for both residents and visitors alike.

From coffee shops to American restaurants, the cake finds its way into the hearts of many. Park Avenue Coffee scores a 7.7 on Foursquare, indicating its popularity among locals. Meanwhile, the Broadway Oyster Bar, with a rating of 9.1, surprises guests with its diverse menu that includes the alluring alligator cheesecake. Whether it's the traditional flavor or a creative twist like red velvet, the city's bakeries and eateries receive accolades for their take on this beloved dessert.

Secrets Behind the Best Gooey Butter Cake

The quest for the perfect Gooey Butter Cake is a journey of sweet discovery. The secret to a sublime Gooey Butter Cake lies in the balance of a dense, rich base with a lusciously sweet and creamy topping. Each bakery in St. Louis adds its unique twist to this classic treat, but there are a few key elements that consistently stand out.

  • Quality Ingredients: The foundation of any great cake; fresh, high-quality eggs, butter, and vanilla extract make a noticeable difference.

  • Texture: A slightly crisp and golden edge with a gooey center is the hallmark of authenticity.

  • Variety: From traditional recipes to innovative flavors like red velvet and pumpkin, variety keeps the love for Gooey Butter Cake alive.

While many bakeries keep their recipes close to the chest, patrons often share that the best versions of Gooey Butter Cake are those that stick to tradition while allowing room for a little creativity. Whether it's a family recipe passed down through generations or a new take from a local coffee shop, the best Gooey Butter Cakes are made with passion and served with pride.

Culinary Delights: Pairing Coffee with Gooey Butter Cake

The perfect coffee pairing can elevate the experience of indulging in a gooey butter cake to new heights. A well-chosen coffee can complement the rich, sweet flavors of the cake, creating a harmonious balance on the palate. Here are some pairing ideas that have been well-received by St. Louis locals:

  • A robust espresso to cut through the sweetness and add a depth of flavor.

  • A smooth latte that mirrors the creamy texture of the cake.

  • A spicy chai latte to contrast the sweetness with its aromatic spices.

Remember, the goal is to enhance the overall tasting experience, so feel free to experiment with different coffee styles until you find your perfect match.


As we've explored the sweet and indulgent world of St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake, it's clear that this local delicacy has captured the hearts of residents and visitors alike. From the traditional to the inventive red velvet and pumpkin variations, each slice offers a taste of St. Louis's rich culinary culture. Whether enjoyed with a cup of excellent coffee at Park Avenue Coffee, savored alongside a meal at Broadway Oyster Bar, or as a treat from the beloved Missouri Baking Company, the gooey butter cake stands out as a must-try dessert. Its widespread acclaim among the city's cafes, bakeries, and restaurants is a testament to its irresistible charm. So, the next time you find yourself in St. Louis, be sure to indulge in a piece of gooey butter cake and experience a beloved piece of the city's sweet history.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Gooey Butter Cake and why is it famous in St. Louis?

Gooey Butter Cake is a rich, sweet dessert that originated in St. Louis, Missouri. It's famous for its dense, buttery texture and a crust that is topped with a layer of sweet, gooey filling. It has become a beloved treat in the area and a symbol of St. Louis's culinary tradition.

Where can I find the best Gooey Butter Cake in St. Louis?

Park Avenue Coffee is voted best Gooey Butter Cake in St. Louis, offering over 76 varieties including fan favorites like Red Velvet and Triple Chocolate. Missouri Baking Company and Russell's on Macklind are also highly praised for their delicious versions of the cake.

Are there any variations of the traditional Gooey Butter Cake?

Yes, there are numerous variations of the traditional Gooey Butter Cake. Some popular ones include the Chocolate Chip Gooey Butter Cake at Russell's on Macklind and the Pumpkin Gooey Butter Bar at The London Tea Room.

Can I find other desserts in St. Louis that are similar to Gooey Butter Cake?

Certainly! St. Louis offers a variety of unique desserts like the alligator cheesecake at Broadway Oyster Bar and the Maple Cheesecake at Vin de Set. These desserts offer a twist on the rich, creamy textures similar to Gooey Butter Cake.

Are there any coffee shops in St. Louis that serve Gooey Butter Cake?

Many coffee shops in St. Louis serve Gooey Butter Cake alongside their beverages. The Mud House, for example, is known for its phenomenal gooey butter cake and coffee pairing. Park Avenue Coffee is another popular spot for enjoying this St. Louis classic with a cup of coffee.

Is Gooey Butter Cake available year-round in St. Louis?

Yes, Gooey Butter Cake is available throughout the year in St. Louis. Many bakeries and coffee shops offer this local specialty as a staple item due to its enduring popularity among residents and visitors alike.

18 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page