top of page

- "The Ultimate Guide to Making and Enjoying Authentic Cincinnati Chili"

Updated: May 8

Cincinnati Chili is a beloved regional dish with a rich culinary tradition that sets it apart from other chili varieties. Known for its unique serving styles, often referred to as 'ways,' and its distinct blend of spices, this comfort food has become an integral part of Cincinnati's identity. From iconic local establishments to its presence in popular culture, the story of Cincinnati Chili is as flavorful as the dish itself. Whether you're a longtime fan or a curious foodie, exploring the world of Cincinnati Chili is sure to be a delectable journey.

Key Takeaways

  • Cincinnati Chili is distinguished by its 'ways' of serving, including the popular 2-way to 5-way presentations that combine spaghetti, chili, cheese, onions, and beans in various combinations.

  • The secret ingredients and spices that give Cincinnati Chili its unique flavor profile include cinnamon, chocolate, and other unexpected elements not typically found in chili.

  • Cincinnati's chili culture is rich with historic eateries like Camp Washington Chili, Price Hill Chili, and Pleasant Ridge Chili & Restaurant, each offering their own take on the classic dish.

  • The dish has a notable presence in popular culture and is a staple at local events and festivals, with celebrity endorsements adding to its fame.

  • Skyline and Gold Star are the two most prominent chili chains in Cincinnati, with a fierce rivalry that divides local opinion and loyalty.

The Unique Flavors of Cincinnati Chili

Understanding the 'Ways' of Serving

Cincinnati Chili is not just a dish; it's a customizable experience. The 'Ways' of serving refer to the various combinations in which the chili is enjoyed. At the heart of this tradition is the simple bowl of chili, but from there, the options expand:

  • Two-Way: Chili served over spaghetti

  • Three-Way: Adding shredded cheese

  • Four-Way: Layering chopped onions

  • Five-Way: Topping with beans

Each 'Way' adds a new dimension to the dish, allowing for a personalized taste experience. The 'Ways' are a testament to the chili's versatility and the creativity of Cincinnati's culinary culture.

The Secret Ingredients and Spices

The brilliance of the Cincinnati Chili spice blend lies in its complex layering of flavors, which sets it apart from other chili varieties. A unique combination of sweet, savory, and aromatic spices creates a distinctive taste that is both comforting and exotic. Among the key spices are cumin, chili powder, and sweet paprika, which provide the foundational warmth and depth of flavor. These are complemented by a surprising twist of cinnamon, allspice, and chocolate, ingredients not typically found in chili.

To truly appreciate the complexity, here's a snapshot of the spices used in a classic Cincinnati Chili recipe:

  • Chili powder and cumin: the quintessential chili spices.

  • Cinnamon and allspice: sweet and warming notes.

  • Clove and cayenne pepper: a hint of spice and heat.

  • Unsweetened chocolate and apple cider vinegar: unique additions that enhance the richness and tanginess.

Understanding the role of each ingredient is essential for anyone looking to recreate this regional specialty at home. The secret to the perfect Cincinnati Chili is not just in the choice of spices, but in their quality and the care with which they are blended.

Comparing Cincinnati Chili to Other Regional Varieties

Cincinnati chili stands out in the American chili landscape with its unique blend of spices and serving styles. Unlike the thick, stew-like consistency of Texas chili, Cincinnati's version is thinner and often served over spaghetti, a dish known as a 'way.' The 'ways' range from a simple 2-way, consisting of spaghetti and chili, to the loaded 5-way, which includes spaghetti, chili, cheese, onions, and beans.

The spices used in Cincinnati chili, such as cinnamon, set it apart from other regional varieties that typically rely on a more straightforward combination of chili peppers and cumin. This distinct flavor profile has made Cincinnati chili a beloved local specialty, with a dedicated following that extends beyond Ohio's borders.

When comparing Cincinnati chili to other regional favorites like a Chicago hotdog or New York City pizza, it's clear that each has its own set of unwavering fans. However, Cincinnati chili's versatility in serving options and its unexpected sweet and savory spice mix offer a culinary experience that's hard to find elsewhere.

Iconic Cincinnati Chili Establishments

Camp Washington Chili: A Local Favorite

Nestled in the heart of the city, Camp Washington Chili stands as a testament to the enduring love for Cincinnati's unique take on this classic American dish. With a history that spans over 75 years, this diner has become a beloved institution, serving up steaming bowls of chili to locals and visitors alike. The establishment's commitment to tradition is evident in every bite, and its reputation is well-deserved, with a 4 out of 5 rating on Tripadvisor and a rank o out of 2019 restaurants in Cincinnati.

Whether you're a first-time visitor or a seasoned patron, the menu offers a variety of ways to enjoy the chili, from the classic bowl to the loaded cheese coney. The diner's unwavering popularity is a clear indicator of its quality and the special place it holds in the hearts of those who've experienced its charm.

Price Hill Chili: A Blend of Tradition and Innovation

Nestled in the heart of West Price Hill, Price Hill Chili stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of Cincinnati chili. With a history that resonates with locals, this establishment has been serving up its unique take on the classic dish for generations. The secret to their success lies in a perfect balance between honoring tradition and embracing innovation.

Customers rave about the chili cheese omelet, a creative twist that marries breakfast with the iconic Cincinnati staple. The chili bowl, too, garners high praise for its rich flavors and comforting warmth. Here's what patrons are saying:

  • Ronald Vieira: "Fresher homemade Chili soup is amazing. Definitely going back!"

  • Milo Boyd: "Chili and cheese omelet Then add onion and bean! OMG hangover be gone!"

  • Tim Knoll: "Chili cheese omelette with side of patties well is the way to go."

The restaurant's popularity is evident in the tips and reviews left by satisfied customers, highlighting not just the food, but the overall experience. It's a place where the community comes together, united by their love for a dish that's as much a part of Cincinnati as the skyline itself.

Pleasant Ridge Chili & Restaurant: A Community Staple

Pleasant Ridge Chili & Restaurant has been a beloved fixture in Cincinnati's dining scene, located at 6032 Montgomery Road. Known for its greasy spoon charm, the restaurant offers a quintessential chili parlor experience that locals and visitors alike cherish. The menu features a variety of chili favorites, including the much-praised chili cheese fries and the classic three-way chili.

The establishment is not just about the food; it's about the atmosphere. A diverse clientele gathers here, creating a vibrant and welcoming environment. Regulars swear by the chili, often declaring it the best in Cincinnati. Whether it's the chili cheese fries that have garnered a loyal following or the double deckers that keep customers coming back, Pleasant Ridge Chili & Restaurant stands out for its quality and community feel.

Cincinnati Chili in Popular Culture

Cincinnati Chili in Movies and TV Shows

Cincinnati Chili has made its mark not only on the taste buds of locals and visitors but also on the silver screen and television. Its unique culinary presence has been featured in various forms of entertainment, reflecting its cultural significance in the region. For instance, the eclectic Melt Cafe gained fame on 'Diners, Drive-ins and Dives' for its creative take on vegan chili, showcasing the dish's versatility.

The Great American Ball Park, home to the Cincinnati Reds, is another venue where the chili tradition is celebrated, with fans often praising the chili bowl as a game-day essential. This iconic dish has woven itself into the fabric of Cincinnati's identity, becoming a symbol of local pride and community.



The Dish's Presence in Local Events and Festivals

Cincinnati Chili is not just a beloved local dish; it's a cultural icon that takes center stage at numerous events and festivals throughout the city. From the annual Taste of Cincinnati to neighborhood chili cook-offs, the dish is celebrated for its unique flavor and its ability to bring the community together.

During these events, attendees can sample chili from various vendors, each offering their own twist on the classic recipe. The friendly competition among chili makers adds a vibrant atmosphere to the festivities. Here's a glimpse of how Cincinnati Chili features in local events:

  • Taste of Cincinnati: The city's largest food festival where chili takes the spotlight.

  • Northside Chili Cook-Off: A neighborhood event showcasing local chili variations.

  • Cincinnati Chili Fest: A festival dedicated to all things chili, including tastings, contests, and live entertainment.

Celebrity Endorsements and Famous Fans

Cincinnati chili has not only captivated the taste buds of locals but has also garnered a following among celebrities and public figures. The allure of this regional specialty has crossed over into the realm of the stars, with various celebrities openly expressing their love for the dish. From actors to athletes, the endorsement of Cincinnati chili by well-known personalities has played a role in its widespread appeal.

  • Sarah Jessica Parker

  • Jason Kelce

These endorsements often come in the form of social media posts, interviews, and even during visits to the city, where celebrities make it a point to stop by famous chili parlors. The shared history and cultural significance of Cincinnati chili add to its charm, making it more than just a meal—it's a part of the city's identity.

Making Cincinnati Chili at Home

Finding the Right Recipe: Tips from Locals

When embarking on the journey to create the perfect pot of Cincinnati Chili, locals emphasize starting with an authentic recipe. The key to authenticity lies in the unique blend of spices and ingredients that give Cincinnati Chili its distinctive flavor. Here are some tips from Cincinnati natives to help you find the right recipe:

  • Seek out recipes that include the classic Cincinnati spices: chili powder, cinnamon, cumin, and allspice.

  • Don't shy away from unconventional ingredients like unsweetened chocolate or apple cider vinegar; these are essential to achieving the correct taste.

  • Pay attention to the meat-to-liquid ratio to ensure your chili has the proper consistency.

Remember, the goal is not just to make chili, but to make Cincinnati Chili, which carries a legacy and a taste profile that's been cherished for generations.

Cooking Techniques and Common Mistakes

Mastering the art of Cincinnati chili requires attention to detail and an understanding of the unique cooking process. The key to a rich and flavorful chili is in the fine texture of the beef and the balance of spices. Begin by adding water, tomato paste, and unsweetened chocolate to a large pot, heating the mixture while stirring for about three minutes. The blend of spices, including chili powder, cinnamon, garlic powder, cumin, allspice, cloves, and a hint of red pepper flakes, is what sets Cincinnati chili apart from other varieties.

To achieve the desired consistency, crumble the raw ground beef into the pot with your fingers, then use a potato masher, whisk, or fork to break up the meat into very fine pieces. This step is crucial; larger chunks can result in a less authentic texture. Bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce the heat to maintain a low boil. Cook uncovered for 1 to 1 1/2 hours, stirring occasionally, until the sauce has thickened significantly.

A common mistake is rushing the cooking process or covering the pot, which can prevent the sauce from reducing properly. Patience is essential to allow the flavors to meld and the sauce to reach the perfect consistency. Serve the chili over thin spaghetti or a hot dog, following the traditional 'Ways' of Cincinnati chili serving.

Serving Suggestions for the Perfect Chili Experience

When it comes to enjoying Cincinnati chili, the presentation and accompaniments can make all the difference. A well-rounded meal enhances the chili's rich flavors and spices. For a truly authentic experience, consider the traditional 'ways' of serving, which include layering the chili over spaghetti and topping it with cheese, onions, and beans, depending on your preference for a 2-way up to a 5-way dish.

Beyond the classic 'ways', there's a world of side dishes that can complement your chili. According to The Kitchn, options range from baked potatoes and cornbread to biscuits. Here's a quick list of sides to consider:

  • Cornbread

  • Baked potatoes

  • Coleslaw

  • Garlic bread

  • Green salad

Finally, don't forget to personalize your chili bowl. Whether it's adding a dollop of sour cream, a sprinkle of cheddar cheese, or a side of chili cheese fries, these finishing touches can elevate your chili to new heights. As one enthusiast suggests, "Chili is the BEST!!!" when it's served just the way you like it.

The Great Chili Debate: Skyline vs. Gold Star

Differences in Recipes and Tastes

The differences in recipes and tastes between Skyline and Gold Star are subtle yet significant to the aficionados of Cincinnati chili. Skyline's version is known for its distinctive hint of cinnamon and chocolate, creating a unique sweet and savory profile. Gold Star, on the other hand, offers a slightly spicier kick, appealing to those who favor a bolder taste.

  • Skyline Chili: Hint of cinnamon and chocolate, sweeter profile

  • Gold Star Chili: Spicier kick, bolder flavor

While both establishments use a similar base of spices, the proportions and additional ingredients are closely guarded secrets that contribute to their distinct flavors. The choice between Skyline and Gold Star often comes down to personal preference, with some Cincinnatians swearing by one brand over the other.

Loyal Customer Bases and Brand Rivalry

The rivalry between Skyline and Gold Star is not just about the taste of their chili; it's deeply rooted in the loyalty of their customer bases. Each brand has cultivated a following that swears by their recipe, with fans often engaging in friendly debates over which chili reigns supreme. This loyalty extends beyond the bowl, with merchandise like t-shirts and hats becoming a common sight among enthusiasts.

The brands also compete through their presence in local grocery stores and markets, offering a range of products that allow fans to enjoy their favorite chili at home. Here's a snapshot of their offerings:

  • Skyline Chili: chili cans, chili crackers, chili dressing, chili hot sauce, microwaveable chili

  • Gold Star Chili: BBQ sauce, BBQ spice, beef jerky, cheese nibs, popcorn, pork rinds

In the midst of this rivalry, a unique aspect of Cincinnati's chili culture emerges. It's not just a dish; it's a lifestyle, a part of the city's identity that locals embrace and visitors quickly learn to appreciate.

Poll Results and Public Opinion

The debate between Skyline and Gold Star has always been a heated topic among Cincinnati chili enthusiasts. Polls reveal a clear preference for Skyline, with 50% of the votes, while Gold Star did not receive any votes in the recent survey. Other establishments like Camp Washington and Pleasant Ridge each garnered 10% of the votes, indicating a loyal but smaller following.

Despite the playful banter and passionate opinions, some residents remain indifferent or critical of the chili, with 20% of participants humorously labeling all options as 'diarrhea'. This sentiment echoes the polarizing nature of Cincinnati chili, which, while beloved by many, is not without its detractors.

The table below summarizes the poll results:

Total voters: 10

Conclusion

Cincinnati Chili is not just a dish; it's a cultural icon that embodies the spirit of The Queen City. From the classic 'ways' of serving it over spaghetti to the mouthwatering chili cheese fries and coneys, this regional specialty has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. Whether you're a die-hard fan of Skyline or a supporter of Camp Washington, the debate over the best Cincinnati Chili is a testament to its significance in the city's culinary landscape. As we've explored the various establishments that serve up this unique blend of flavors, it's clear that Cincinnati Chili is more than just food—it's a beloved tradition that continues to be a source of pride for Cincinnatians. So, the next time you find yourself in Cincinnati, dive into a bowl of this hometown favorite and experience a piece of local history that's as rich and savory as the chili itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Cincinnati chili unique?

Cincinnati chili is known for its unique blend of spices, which often includes cinnamon, chocolate, or cocoa, and is served over spaghetti or a hot dog, rather than alone or with bread.

How is Cincinnati chili traditionally served?

Cincinnati chili is traditionally served in 'ways': 2-way with spaghetti and chili, 3-way adds cheese, 4-way includes onions or beans, and 5-way has both onions and beans.

Can I make Cincinnati chili at home?

Yes, you can make Cincinnati chili at home by finding an authentic recipe online and following the unique cooking techniques and spice combinations that characterize this regional dish.

What are some iconic Cincinnati chili establishments?

Iconic establishments include Camp Washington Chili, Price Hill Chili, and Pleasant Ridge Chili & Restaurant, each offering their own take on the classic dish.

Is there a rivalry between different Cincinnati chili brands?

Yes, there is a friendly rivalry, particularly between Skyline Chili and Gold Star Chili, which are two of the most popular chili chains in Cincinnati.

Where can I find Cincinnati chili outside of Ohio?

Cincinnati chili can be found in various states across the U.S., often in restaurants that specialize in regional cuisines, or by purchasing canned or packaged mixes from Cincinnati-based brands.

6 views0 comments

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page